By Tom Kapitany (Crystal World) — Geologist and Palaeontologist
The opening of the Abu Dhabi Natural History Museum is nothing short of extraordinary. Billions of dollars have gone into building a world‑class institution, filled with dinosaurs, meteorites, gems and natural history specimens sourced from private collectors, commercial dealers and field scientists. It is proof that cooperation — not academic gatekeeping, is what drives science forward.
While this museum celebrates collaboration, the Society of Vertebrate Palaeontology (SVP) continues to undermine projects like this. Instead of embracing the opportunities such collections provide, SVP members cling to outdated dogma that fossils must only reside in “approved” repositories. Their stance is not about science — it’s about control.
Academic obstruction
Two of SVP’s academic members, Dr Thomas Carr of Carthage College and Dr Mark Uhen of George Mason University, exemplify this obstructionist mindset. Both have publicly opposed the private and commercial sale of fossils, demonising the very networks of dealers and collectors that make museums like Abu Dhabi’s possible.
Their refusal to study or publish specimens outside their control is not scientific integrity — it is academic arrogance. The result? Potentially groundbreaking discoveries are ignored simply because they don’t fit SVP’s rigid ideology.
On display in Abu Dhabi are two headline Tyrannosaurus rex specimens:
-
“Stan”, discovered and prepared by the Black Hills Institute, a fossil that has already transformed our understanding of tyrannosaurs.
-
A new, unpublished specimen, potentially one of the most significant finds in decades.
Yet these fossils sit in plain view while SVP academics turn their backs. Carr, Uhen and their colleagues refuse to study or publish specimens that aren’t locked inside their approved repositories. This isn’t science — it’s obstruction. By refusing to engage with specimens like Stan or the new T. rex, SVP members deliberately stall discovery. They would rather let knowledge stagnate than admit that private collectors and commercial dealers are essential to advancing palaeontology.
The Abu Dhabi museum proves the opposite: when cooperation is embraced, the result is a world‑class institution filled with real fossils, not replicas, and brimming with untapped scientific potential.
A museum built on cooperation
The Abu Dhabi Natural History Museum has not only acquired specimens — it has hired world‑class scientists across disciplines, including Australian geoscientist Stephen Petkovski. This is how science should work: collaboration between professionals, collectors and institutions. Without dealers and private collectors, museums would be filled with replicas, and research would grind to a halt.
SVP’s hostility toward commercialisation is echoed by certain government departments, particularly in Australia, where fossil export restrictions are enforced by dysfunctional bureaucracies. These policies, often influenced by academics with vested interests, distort facts and mislead decision‑makers. Such behaviour borders on misconduct, prioritising control over truth.
Museums need professional palaeontological dealers as well as private collectors to support them. Most museums are filled with collections from deceased collectors — proof that private individuals have always been central to the science. Attempts to erase their role are not only dishonest, they are destructive.
The Abu Dhabi Natural History Museum is a triumph of cooperation. It stands as a rebuke to the SVP and academics like Carr and Uhen who would rather police science than advance it. Palaeontology belongs to the world and without the contributions of dealers, collectors and private individuals, museums of this calibre would not exist.
